How far can a judge go in striking unreasonable terms?
The North Carolina Supreme Court recently clarified the limited power judges have to strike unreasonable terms in non-compete agreements.1 Citing historic case law, the Court made clear that judges are not at liberty to rewrite contracts for the parties. There remains one exception to this general principle known as the “blue-pencil rule.” This rule permits the Court not to enforce certain sections of an agreement that it finds to be unreasonable.
The blue-pencil rule does not allow a judge to rewrite the terms of a contract or cross out a term to make a new provision. This rule simply allows the judge to refuse to enforce certain sections of a noncompete agreement that are unreasonable.
The blue-pencil rule is most commonly used with territorial restrictions that attempt to prevent a former employee from working in certain geographic areas. If several different territorial areas are listed in distinct and separate provisions, the court can “blue-pencil” or refuse to enforce specific territories that are overly board. However, if only one restricted territory is listed in the agreement, the judge has no power to revise that provision.
Noncompete agreements are rarely straightforward, and there are often many loopholes that can leave them unenforceable. If you have questions about a noncompete agreement, attorney Adam Hocutt has experience litigating these issues in North Carolina courts.
1. Beverage Sys. of the Carolinas, LLC v. Associated Bev. Repair, LLC, 2016 N.C. LEXIS 177 (N.C. Mar. 18, 2016)

CATEGORIES
Contact an Attorney
Our attorney offer specialized guidance and representation in a variety of practice areas.

REMEMBER: Always speak with your own attorney
This information is provided for informational purposes only; it is not offered as and does not constitute legal advice.
More Insights and Resources
Learn more about what to expect when facing a family law dispute in Charlotte, North Carolina from Family Law attorneys at Dozier Miller Law Group
The REAL ID is Coming – Are You Ready?
Most of us don’t think much about our driver’s licenses—until we realize they might not be enough…
What the End of the TCJA Could Mean for Your Will, Trust, and Estate Plans
Planning for the future is one of the best ways to protect your family and make sure…
4 Legal Things to Make Sure You’re Doing in 2025
The start of a new year is the perfect opportunity to make sure your legal bases are…
Birthright Citizenship in 2024: What Immigrant Families Should Know
The outcome of the 2024 presidential election has brought immigration and citizenship into the national spotlight in…
North Carolina’s Personal Injury Laws: What You Need to Know
When you or a loved one is injured in an accident, it can feel like your whole…
Inheritance and Estate Planning Mistakes to Avoid
Avoid costly estate planning mistakes with our tips. Learn how to protect your assets and plan for...
Legislative Changes in Child Welfare
Being a grandparent comes with its own set of joys and challenges. When family dynamics shift, particularly…
Starting a Business in Charlotte in 2025: Your Essential Guide
As the city of Charlotte continues to grow and innovate, 2025 presents a fantastic opportunity for entrepreneurs….
Divorce, Explained
Divorce is a challenging time, filled with a mix of emotions and legal hurdles. In North Carolina,…
Understanding Domestic Violence and Finding Support
October is Domestic Violence Awareness Month, a time for us to open our hearts and truly understand…